WOO logo

On this page

Lucky Larry's Lobstermania

Introduction

In an ongoing effort to demystify the operation of slot machines, I provide a detailed analysis of the IGT game Lucky Larry's Lobstermania, using insights from an academic study. The document titled 'PAR Sheets, Probabilities, and Slot Machine Play: Implications for Problem and Non-Problem Gambling' was authored by Kevin A. Harrigan and Mike Dixon from the University of Waterloo, located in Ontario, Canada. This research came to light via the Canadian Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, for which I commend the Canadian government. This webpage aims to deepen the analysis of Lobstermania beyond the findings shared in Harrigan and Dixon's paper.

The authors of the paper obtained par sheets It's important to recognize that there are various versions of Lobstermania that feature subtle variations in the paytable and bonus round specifics.

Harrigan and Dixon provided the symbol distributions for two Lobstermania versions, corresponding to return rates of 85.0% and 96.2%. It’s evident that the higher payout version contains a greater quantity of high-value symbols and that those symbols are spread out more evenly across the five reels. For instance, the 85.0% version has the clams distributed as 10, 8, 3, 4, 7 across the reels, while the 96.2% version distributes them as 6, 6, 5, 6, 6. Nevertheless, the counts for the key symbols like wilds, scatters, and bonuses are identical in both iterations.

Reel Strips

Lobstermania Symbol Distribution — 85.0%

Lobstermania Symbol Distribution — 96.2%

Symbol Reel 1 Reel 2 Reel 3 Reel 4 Reel 5
Wild 2 2 1 4 2
Logo 4 3 3 3 4
Buoy 3 4 3 8 5
Boat 4 3 4 3 4
Light House 3 4 6 3 7
Tuna 4 3 6 6 6
Clam 10 8 3 4 7
Sea Gull 3 9 4 10 5
Star Fish 10 3 10 7 8
Bonus 2 5 6 0 0
Scatter 2 2 2 2 2
Total 47 46 48 50 50

While Harrigan and Dixon do not specify the exact arrangement of symbols on the reels, the sequence does not influence gameplay unless scatter symbols can appear together on the same reel, which is unlikely. The hypothetical reel configuration based on the 85.0% version is as follows.

Symbol Reel 1 Reel 2 Reel 3 Reel 4 Reel 5
Wild 2 2 1 4 2
Logo 4 4 3 4 4
Buoy 4 4 5 4 5
Boat 6 4 4 4 4
Light House 5 4 6 6 7
Tuna 6 4 5 6 7
Clam 6 6 5 6 6
Sea Gull 5 6 5 6 6
Star Fish 5 5 6 8 7
Bonus 2 5 6 0 0
Scatter 2 2 2 2 2
Total 47 46 48 50 50

Lobstermania Symbol Distribution — 85.0% Reel Strips

In gameplay terms, the method consists of selecting 5 random numbers, one for each reel, and associating each number with a position on its respective reel. For example, if a number drawn for reel 1 is 37, it corresponds to the symbol in the topmost row. In this scenario, reel 1 would display a Clam at the top, a Star Fish in the middle, and a Boat at the bottom.

Symbol Reel 1 Reel 2 Reel 3 Reel 4 Reel 5
1 Tuna Clam Boat Sea Gull Clam
2 Star Fish Buoy Star Fish Tuna Wild
3 Clam Light House Clam Buoy Boat
4 Light House Clam Bonus Sea Gull Logo
5 Scatter Buoy Light House Scatter Buoy
6 Clam Light House Boat Buoy Star Fish
7 Star Fish Bonus Logo Star Fish Light House
8 Bonus Sea Gull Star Fish Sea Gull Tuna
9 Logo Clam Bonus Tuna Star Fish
10 Scatter Boat Light House Wild Light House
11 Buoy Sea Gull Star Fish Buoy Sea Gull
12 Clam Tuna Bonus Tuna Wild
13 Star Fish Boat Tuna Star Fish Tuna
14 Buoy Bonus Star Fish Logo Buoy
15 Clam Star Fish Clam Sea Gull Boat
16 Star Fish Sea Gull Sea Gull Tuna Clam
17 Logo Wild Star Fish Wild Tuna
18 Light House Bonus Wild Logo Buoy
19 Clam Sea Gull Bonus Light House Star Fish
20 Wild Light House Light House Buoy Clam
21 Sea Gull Logo Sea Gull Sea Gull Scatter
22 Star Fish Wild Star Fish Boat Buoy
23 Wild Buoy Tuna Clam Star Fish
24 Bonus Clam Clam Star Fish Tuna
25 Clam Bonus Boat Light House Clam
26 Boat Sea Gull Tuna Sea Gull Buoy
27 Star Fish Clam Star Fish Boat Boat
28 Tuna Scatter Bonus Clam Light House
29 Clam Logo Tuna Buoy Tuna
30 Star Fish Tuna Light House Sea Gull Logo
31 Tuna Sea Gull Star Fish Boat Light House
32 Logo Scatter Scatter Light House Sea Gull
33 Clam Star Fish Light House Star Fish Clam
34 Star Fish Clam Logo Tuna Logo
35 Boat Boat Sea Gull Sea Gull Star Fish
36 Light House Logo Star Fish Buoy Boat
37 Clam Sea Gull Scatter Star Fish Light House
38 Star Fish Clam Buoy Clam Tuna
39 Boat Bonus Tuna Buoy Sea Gull
40 Tuna Star Fish Logo Sea Gull Star Fish
41 Buoy Sea Gull Bonus Star Fish Light House
42 Sea Gull Buoy Star Fish Clam Clam
43 Logo Light House Light House Logo Logo
44 Clam Clam Sea Gull Wild Sea Gull
45 Star Fish Tuna Buoy Buoy Star Fish
46 Boat Sea Gull Boat Sea Gull Clam
47 Sea Gull   Tuna Star Fish Sea Gull
48     Buoy Scatter Light House
49       Tuna Scatter
50       Wild Star Fish

Below is the pay table for Lobstermania. All winning combinations must align from the left. The wild symbol works as a substitute for any symbol that contributes to a win.

Pay Table

There are a total of 47 × 46 × 48 × 50 × 50 = 259,440,000 different potential outcomes in Lobstermania. The following table outlines how many of these combinations yield each specific win. These results were computed using a program that involved five nested loops to tally winnings from all possible combinations.

Lobstermania Pay Table

Symbol 5 in a row 4 in a row 3 in a row 2 in a row
Wild 10000 500 100 5
Logo 1000 200 40 2
Buoy 500 100 25  
Boat 500 100 25  
Light House 500 50 10  
Tuna 250 50 10  
Clam 200 30 5  
Sea Gull 200 30 5  
Star Fish 150 30 5  

Line Pay Math

Lobstermania Line Pay Combinations

The upcoming table displays the probability associated with achieving each possible win. This is calculated by taking the number of winning combinations from the prior table and dividing it by the total number of 259,440,000 combinations. The cumulative figure in the lower right corner indicates a hit frequency per line (the likelihood of securing any win) of 3.25%.

Symbol 5 in a row 4 in a row 3 in a row 2 in a row Total
Wild 32 704 7,300 212,000 220,036
Logo 5,008 36,256 249,400 2,860,000 3,150,664
Buoy 9,968 59,856 220,400   290,224
Boat 6,204 44,968 313,900   365,072
Light House 13,086 59,122 442,900   515,108
Tuna 16,672 86,520 412,000   515,192
Clam 34,416 156,128 974,400   1,164,944
Sea Gull 26,838 163,142 459,000   648,980
Star Fish 72,440 288,640 1,201,200   1,562,280
Total 184,664 895,336 4,280,500 3,072,000 8,432,500

Lobstermania Line Pay Probabilities

The following table demonstrates how each winning combination contributes to the overall return. Each cell contains the product of the win probability (from the previous table) and the value indicated in the pay table. The final cell presents a total return of 55.28% from line pays.

Symbol 5 in a row 4 in a row 3 in a row 2 in a row Total
Wild 0.00000012 0.00000271 0.00002814 0.00081714 0.00084812
Logo 0.00001930 0.00013975 0.00096130 0.01102374 0.01214409
Buoy 0.00003842 0.00023071 0.00084952   0.00111866
Boat 0.00002391 0.00017333 0.00120991   0.00140715
Light House 0.00005044 0.00022788 0.00170714   0.00198546
Tuna 0.00006426 0.00033349 0.00158804   0.00198578
Clam 0.00013265 0.00060179 0.00375578   0.00449023
Sea Gull 0.00010345 0.00062882 0.00176920   0.00250146
Star Fish 0.00027922 0.00111255 0.00462997   0.00602174
Total 0.00071178 0.00345103 0.01649900 0.01184089 0.03250270

Players receive a credit for a scatter pay symbol if it appears anywhere on the screen. Scatter wins are determined based on the total amount wagered. The next table illustrates the figure of scatter symbols per reel, total symbols present on each reel, and the probability of encountering a scatter on that reel, calculated as 3 × (column 2)/(column 3). The multiplication by 3 accounts for the three visible positions on every reel.

The following table demonstrates how each winning combination contributes to the overall return. Each cell contains the product of the win probability (from the previous table) and the value indicated in the pay table. The final cell presents a total return of 55.28% from line pays.

Symbol 5 in a row 4 in a row 3 in a row 2 in a row Total
Wild 0.00123343 0.00135677 0.00281375 0.00408572 0.00948967
Logo 0.01930311 0.02794943 0.03845205 0.02204749 0.10775208
Buoy 0.01921061 0.02307123 0.02123805   0.06351989
Boat 0.01195652 0.01733272 0.03024784   0.05953708
Light House 0.02521970 0.01139416 0.01707138   0.05368525
Tuna 0.01606537 0.01667438 0.01588036   0.04862010
Clam 0.02653099 0.01805365 0.01877891   0.06336355
Sea Gull 0.02068918 0.01886471 0.00884598   0.04839986
Star Fish 0.04188252 0.03337650 0.02314986   0.09840888
Total 0.18209143 0.16807354 0.17647818 0.02613321 0.55277636

Scatter Pay

The subsequent table outlines the probabilities and contributions to the return for having between 0 to 5 scatter symbols. The lower right corner reveals that the scatter pay feature provides a 10.65% return in the game's overall return.

Lobstermania Scatters per Reel

Reel Scatters Total Symbols
on Reel
Scatter
Probability
1 2 47 0.127660
2 2 46 0.130435
3 2 48 0.125000
4 2 50 0.120000
5 2 50 0.120000

Lobstermania Scatter Pay Probabilities and Returns

A player activates the bonus feature by landing the bonus symbol on reels 1, 2, and 3 along any active pay line. The next table provides the probabilities for obtaining the bonus symbol on the first three reels. The lower right cell indicates the chance of triggering the bonus on any active pay line is 0.06%, or 1 in 1,730. If a player bets on all 15 active pay lines, the probability of triggering the bonus in a single spin rises to 0.87%, or roughly 1 in 115.

Scatters Pays Probability Return
5 200 0.000030 0.005994
4 25 0.001054 0.026351
3 5 0.014821 0.074106
2 0 0.104168 0.000000
1 0 0.365929 0.000000
0 0 0.513998 0.000000
Total   1.000000 0.106451

Bonus

The bonus game consists of three segments, elaborated as follows:

Lobstermania Bonus Symbols per Reel

Reel Bonus
Symbols
Total Symbols
on Reel
Bonus
Probability
1 2 47 0.042553
2 5 46 0.108696
3 6 48 0.125000
Product     0.000578

There are three potential outcomes for the number of lobster traps: 2, 3, and 4, each being equally likely. Therefore, the expected number of traps is 3.

  • Number of lobster traps.
  • Number of lobsters per trap.
  • Size/win of each lobster.

Each trap may yield either 2 or 3 lobsters, with both possibilities equally probable. As a result, the average number of lobsters per trap is 2.5.

The value of each lobster can range from 5 to 250. Each prize has an associated weighting, as outlined in the accompanying table. The game might select a random integer from 1 to 322 and correspond it to a weight based on this table. The expected average winning per lobster is noted to be 44.02.

The average win from the bonus can be calculated with the formula (average traps) × (average lobsters per trap) × (average win per lobster) = 3 × 2.5 × 44.021739, resulting in an average of approximately 330.16.

Lobstermania Bonus — Lobster Wins

Pays Weight Probability Return
5 5 0.015528 0.077640
6 5 0.015528 0.093168
7 5 0.015528 0.108696
8 5 0.015528 0.124224
10 20 0.062112 0.621118
12 10 0.031056 0.372671
15 10 0.031056 0.465839
20 20 0.062112 1.242236
22 20 0.062112 1.366460
25 20 0.062112 1.552795
27 20 0.062112 1.677019
30 19 0.059006 1.770186
35 22 0.068323 2.391304
45 24 0.074534 3.354037
50 19 0.059006 2.950311
55 15 0.046584 2.562112
60 15 0.046584 2.795031
65 15 0.046584 3.027950
70 15 0.046584 3.260870
75 15 0.046584 3.493789
100 10 0.031056 3.105590
150 8 0.024845 3.726708
250 5 0.015528 3.881988
Total 322 1.000000 44.021739

The expected return for the bonus feature can be calculated as (bonus probability) × (average win per bonus), yielding approximately 0.190890.

The following table summarizes the various winning avenues available in the game. The bottom right cell indicates an expected return of 85.012%. In other words, for every dollar wagered, the player can anticipate a return of around 85 cents.

Summary

The paper by Harrigan and Dixon stated that they received par sheets for seven different versions of Lobstermania, with available return rates of 85.0%, 87.5%, 90.0%, 92.5%, 94.0%, 95.0%, and 96.2%.

Lobstermania Summary

Item Return
Line Pays 55.278%
Scatter 10.645%
Bonus 19.089%
Total 85.012%

Enjoy the video below, where I demonstrate how to analyze Lucky Larry's Lobstermania using Excel.

Video

I have extensively analyzed numerous slot machines. Here’s a compilation of my findings:


Direct link: https://youtu.be/XyWex4nMjq0?si=ni68uo2_E4_MK8Ig .

More Deconstructions

A detailed analysis of a well-known MGM progressive game.